Many co-determination bodies work with committees, a kind of subdivision of the council that typically focuses on a type of file. This is enormously convenient, a council member is generally very busy, and if all files also have to be prepared together, it often becomes completely unmanageable. It is also a way to combine knowledge and expertise on a type of subject in a formalized way. Nevertheless, committees can still be quite complex; how should a committee relate to the council as a whole (during the internal meetings)? What if the committee has a different opinion than the council as a whole? Can a committee be divided further (into subcommittees, for example)? And what regulations determine whether or not committees are used at all? We address these questions in this handout. The content of committee work, and its role in forming council opinions, is discussed in more detail in the handbook on council opinion and meeting cycles.
It is important to realize that not every co-determination body works with committees, certainly not smaller or less busy councils/programme committees. Sometimes they (also) work with file-holders, who then fulfill the preparatory role that a committee would otherwise have. If this is the case for you, this guide will not always be directly applicable, but the principles are still useful to understand!
Wat is a committee?
A committee is a formalized group of council members who focus on a type of file. Common committees are the:
• Finance Committee, which deals with the budget cycle and all related files,
• Education Committee, which deals with education policy-related matters such as the OER and selection and admission procedures
• Legal Affairs Committee, which deals with matters of a legal nature such as the co-determination regulations, administrative and management regulations, by-laws, etc,
• Facilities Committee, which deals with campus-related matters such as housing.
This is by no means a complete list. Some councils work with only a handful of committees, some have as many as 10, some use none. Some councils choose to have only a few committees but divide them further into files. Ultimately, the point of a committee is to formalize a division of labor and pool expertise. Exactly what form is used for this is not that important. Nor will it always be clear which file belongs to which committee. Perhaps it belongs to more than one committee, or you need expertise from several committees. In which cases they work together.
Whether committees are used, how they function, and what type of files belong to which committee are formally described in the HR document of the council in question. This same HR document should also describe how it is determined who serves on which committee. Often this is simply determined at the beginning of the term based on motivation, expertise and staffing. It is also important to know how to establish a new (temporary) committee. You may also come across a file during your tenure that is not a good fit for any of the existing committees. For a permanent new committee, the HR document may need to be changed; for a temporary committee, they may not. Make sure you know what your HR-document says about this and consider adding something about it if nothing is mentioned.
How does a committee relate to the council as a whole?
So, a committee is a subdivision of the council. As we have also seen in the handout about council opinion and meeting cycles, a committee is mainly in charge of preparing files and forming a kind of advice for internal meetings. The council decides what the council opinion is, and thus what the council will propagate in these meetings. In turn, it is often up to the committee to prepare a letter for the executive that goes to the executive after approval from the internal meeting. This document sets out the council’s opinion and requirements. The committee also prepares agenda items for the consultation meeting. At the consultation meeting the committee chair, or the most involved committee member, usually takes the floor during that agenda item. After the file handling process, the committee takes over again, completing what needs to be completed. For example, they conduct wrap-up meetings with the policy staff involved, consider the next steps of the file, and monitor the implementation of commitments made by the executive.
So, we see a collaborative relationship between the committee and the board. The committee prepares papers, conducts research, forms a kind of “expert opinion” for the entire board, and reports to the rest of the board during internal deliberations. As such, the council needs the committee. But the same is true the other way around: at crucial moments in committee work, the committee needs a council opinion from the internal meeting. For example: the committee cannot start writing a letter to the executive if they don’t yet know what opinion it should contain.
But what if the committee has a certain opinion after the committee work, but the council disagrees? Surely the committee has the experts, right? This, of course, is an interesting situation. Expertise or not, by definition all council members have the right to help determine council opinion. If the committee recommendation is not adopted, there is often a good reason for this. It is then up to the committee to try to convince the council anyways, and then, if necessary, to comply with the council’s opinion.

